It saddens me to admit as an proud Indian, but its true Yes, Government of India's Law Minister Salman Khurshid lied about his spouse's assets. According to Indian election laws, it is mandatory for candidates running in election, so Mr. Salman Khurshid duly filed his and his family asset details! Here is the link of his disclosure put up by association for democratic reforms:
So on 2009, the minister & his family was found to be doing well! Good for them, Mrs. Khurshid did not own any house on her name, but Mr. Khurshid stated she owned:
Agricultural Land
45,00,000 45 Lacs+
JOINT WITH CHILDREN - AREA : 90 NALI 17.5 MUTTHI LAND
Non Agricultural Land
10,20,000 10 Lacs+
JOINT WITH CHILDREN - AREA :11.90 ACRES LAND
For those who don't know what a lac is, it is 100 thousand, a crore is 10 million.
Fine, still no problem! Doing well and owning property is not a crime, but when in 2011 the Union Ministers were told to give current assets, which started showing first chinks in his armor! His assets found to be skyrocketed from 26 million to 62 million INR! http://myneta.info/unionministers2011/candidate.php?candidate_id=29 gives us the details:
He & his family had Rs.1,44,42,965 (14 million) in cash only. He had 7 million himself, when his total salary for that period of 2 years was less than 2 million! So how can have that much of cash??? Since this was in public domain and I am ordinary citizen, I hoped that media will take up this matter. Somehow Minister managed stay out of trouble!
In 2011, Mrs. Khurshid is found to have following lands & buildings:
Agricultural Land
AGRI LAND VILL.SATOLI, DISTT. NAINITAL PROP. IN THE NAME OF MY WIFE AND THREE DEPENDENT SONS
Total Area
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
47,00,000 47 Lacs+
AGRI LAND VILL.ROHILAPUR, DISTT. GAUTAM BUDH NAGAR PROP. IN THE NAME OF MY WIFE AND THREE DEPENDENT SONS
Total Area 31 BIGHA 15 BISWA
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
1,30,81,000 1 Crore+
AGRI LAND VILL. DHARAMPUR, DISTT. FARRUKHABAD PROP. IN THE NAME OF MY WIFE AND THREE DEPENDENT SONS
Total Area 60 BIGHAS
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
15,00,000 15 Lacs+
No detail was given for purchase date, we will find that this was not full disclosure; which will be a criminal case! Since no declaration was given about the income of his family, I thought may be someone is doing exceedingly well in his household.
2 Building Mrs. Khurshid received gift from her father seemed to be shown of highly low value:
APARTMENT IN GOA, H.NO.129/4 BERNARD SIMAO RESORTS, BEHIND HOTEL CALANGUDE GOA, THESE APARMENTS HAVE BEEN PURCHASED BY FATHER AND GIFTED TO HER
Total Area 110 SQ.MT.
Built Up Area
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
4,29,200 4 Lacs+
APARTMENT IN GOA, H.NO.129/4 BERNARD SIMAO RESORTS, BEHIND HOTEL CALANGUDE GOA, THESE APARMENTS HAVE BEEN PURCHASED BY FATHER AND GIFTED TO HER
Total Area 102 SQ.MT.
Built Up Area
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
3,94,400 3 Lacs+
You can't even rent those premises for 6 months at the price mentioned, So again Mr. Khurshid deliberately understated this data also! These disclosures are proper legal disclosure and deliberate falsification is a crime, as Law Minister of India Mr. Khurshid is well aware of that fact. Still it looks like allegation not evidence, Right! Then came the final revelation is 2012, when Mrs. Khurshid came up to fight local assembly elections.
Here is the clinching evidence http://myneta.info/up2012/candidate.php?candidate_id=1114 Mrs. Khurshid's disclosure
She states that same family asset is 48 million and not 62 million, poor Salman, surely in 2012 your bad times has come up; But Devil lies in details:
This time election commission had asked to furnish income also and Mrs. Khurshid complies ( and I copy & paste ):
Person Financial Year Taxable Income
Mrs. Khurshid 2010 - 2011 Rs 3,07,102 ~ 3 Lacs+
Mr. Khurshid 2010 - 2011 Rs 8,61,115 ~ 8 Lacs+
dependent1 2010 - 2011 Rs 1,48,970 ~ 1 Lacs+
dependent2 2010 - 2011 Rs 1,51,890 ~ 1 Lacs+
OMG! No Bill gates or Donald Trump or Ambani scale earning? Then how could he or Mrs. Khurshid purchase all these land!
Those huge cash given in 2011 are now back in the banks! Good good, has Mr. Khurshid shown the interest of the bank accounts inn the taxable income from Rs. 12.5 million (1,25 crore) in taxable income??? Not clear, facts show very less chance of being so! At least 5 lacs of bank interest is not shown in taxable income!
Remember those buildings Mrs. Khurshid received from her father as gift, they are shown at 15 lacs and not 4 lacs, still nowhere near the real value of a beachfront property at Calanghute, Goa. She further states these were not gifts but "Inherited". Another discrepancy!
RESIDENT FLAT A BERNARD SIMON COMPLEX CANDILIM GOA
Total Area
Built Up Area 2000Sq.fit
Whether Inherited Y
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
15,00,000 15 Lacs+
RES FLAT B BERNARD SIMON COMPLEX CANDOLIM GOA
Total Area
Built Up Area 2000Sq.ft.
Whether Inherited Y
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
15,00,000 15 Lacs+
She further states, she owns a residential building since 2002, which Salman had never mentioned in his previous disclosures, neither in 2009 nor in 2011 ( Once maybe a mistake, twice proves a pattern for a crime), how can you forget to mention something you own for nearly a decade,Mr. Khurshid, when you don't really own that much.:)
VILL.SATOLI TEH DIST NENITAL
Total Area
Built Up Area 4Nali
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2002-11-15
Purchase Cost 1400000.00
Development Cost 0.00
16,50,000 16 Lacs+
Louise Khurshid also mentioned that she had 6 plots (huge ones) not 3 as Salman khurshid had stated, and the purchase dates show that she had most of them before 2009 (Marked in Red) also!
JAFAR,KHURSHID ,SAMAR AND UMAR VILL.STORI DIST NENITAL
Total Area 90Nali
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2002-03-31
Purchase Cost 814765.00
Development Cost 0.00
58,56,000 58 Lacs+
JAFAR,KHURSHID ,SAMAR AND UMAR VILL.STORI DIST NENITAL
Total Area 19Nali
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2001-03-30
Purchase Cost 497000.00
Development Cost 0.00
14,96,000 14 Lacs+
JAFAR,SAMAR,UMAR VILL.DHARMPUR BLOOK KAYMGANJ JANPAD FARRUKHABAD
Total Area 32Bidha
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2010-03-09
Purchase Cost 820500.00
Development Cost 0.00
12,00,000 12 Lacs+
JAFAR,SAMAR,UMAR VILL.DHARMPUR BLOOK KAYMGANJ JANPAD FARRUKHABAD
Total Area 31Bidha
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2010-03-09
Purchase Cost 775000.00
Development Cost 0.00
8,50,000 8 Lacs+
JAFAR,SAMAR,UMAR VILL.GANIPUR JOGPUR BLOCK NVABGAN JANPAD FARRUKHABAD
Total Area 31Bidha
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2010-03-09
Purchase Cost 775000.00
Development Cost 0.00
8,50,000 8 Lacs+
JAFAR,SAMAR,UMAR VILL.ROHILA DIST GOTAM BUDDHNAGAR
Total Area 30Bidha
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2006-01-01
Purchase Cost 300000.00
Development Cost 0.00
1,20,00,000 1 Crore+
That means Lousie Khurshid bought land worth 28 lakh in just one day, 9th March 2010! Now her annual income is just 3 lakh, total family income is just 13 lakh a year! So what was the source of this money. Please explain!
If it is just astute financial planning, we demand to know the details.
They claim to be social workers and devoted their life well-being of poor people, when we in India, have highest number of malnutrition cases, poverty is increasing, global economy in turmoil, he himself & his family goes scouting for agricultural land, which are close to F1 racing circuit at Goutam Buddhanagar & owning more 40% of a cold storage ( Value shown Rs. 0) ! On some searching on google, I find that kaimganj area has just 4 cold storage with combined capacity of 2545 mt., the value can't be 0.
So some pointed questions for them.
1. Name the sources of Income for Mrs. Louise Khurshid's one day land buying spree on 9th march 2010 amounting over 28 lacs?
2. Name the sources of Income for purchase of following cars ( as they are shown as dependent and having taxable income of 1 lakh each and they also don't have car loans)?
3. Why are they buying agricultural land and showing no development cost, are they doing real farming? if so, how many people they employ? Why their salary will not go under development cost?
4. What are their agricultural income from farming & cold storage? Why are they not showing them in any asset & income disclosures?
So on 2009, the minister & his family was found to be doing well! Good for them, Mrs. Khurshid did not own any house on her name, but Mr. Khurshid stated she owned:
Agricultural Land
45,00,000 45 Lacs+
JOINT WITH CHILDREN - AREA : 90 NALI 17.5 MUTTHI LAND
Non Agricultural Land
10,20,000 10 Lacs+
JOINT WITH CHILDREN - AREA :11.90 ACRES LAND
For those who don't know what a lac is, it is 100 thousand, a crore is 10 million.
Fine, still no problem! Doing well and owning property is not a crime, but when in 2011 the Union Ministers were told to give current assets, which started showing first chinks in his armor! His assets found to be skyrocketed from 26 million to 62 million INR! http://myneta.info/unionministers2011/candidate.php?candidate_id=29 gives us the details:
He & his family had Rs.1,44,42,965 (14 million) in cash only. He had 7 million himself, when his total salary for that period of 2 years was less than 2 million! So how can have that much of cash??? Since this was in public domain and I am ordinary citizen, I hoped that media will take up this matter. Somehow Minister managed stay out of trouble!
In 2011, Mrs. Khurshid is found to have following lands & buildings:
Agricultural Land
AGRI LAND VILL.SATOLI, DISTT. NAINITAL PROP. IN THE NAME OF MY WIFE AND THREE DEPENDENT SONS
Total Area
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
47,00,000 47 Lacs+
AGRI LAND VILL.ROHILAPUR, DISTT. GAUTAM BUDH NAGAR PROP. IN THE NAME OF MY WIFE AND THREE DEPENDENT SONS
Total Area 31 BIGHA 15 BISWA
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
1,30,81,000 1 Crore+
AGRI LAND VILL. DHARAMPUR, DISTT. FARRUKHABAD PROP. IN THE NAME OF MY WIFE AND THREE DEPENDENT SONS
Total Area 60 BIGHAS
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
15,00,000 15 Lacs+
No detail was given for purchase date, we will find that this was not full disclosure; which will be a criminal case! Since no declaration was given about the income of his family, I thought may be someone is doing exceedingly well in his household.
2 Building Mrs. Khurshid received gift from her father seemed to be shown of highly low value:
APARTMENT IN GOA, H.NO.129/4 BERNARD SIMAO RESORTS, BEHIND HOTEL CALANGUDE GOA, THESE APARMENTS HAVE BEEN PURCHASED BY FATHER AND GIFTED TO HER
Total Area 110 SQ.MT.
Built Up Area
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
4,29,200 4 Lacs+
APARTMENT IN GOA, H.NO.129/4 BERNARD SIMAO RESORTS, BEHIND HOTEL CALANGUDE GOA, THESE APARMENTS HAVE BEEN PURCHASED BY FATHER AND GIFTED TO HER
Total Area 102 SQ.MT.
Built Up Area
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
3,94,400 3 Lacs+
You can't even rent those premises for 6 months at the price mentioned, So again Mr. Khurshid deliberately understated this data also! These disclosures are proper legal disclosure and deliberate falsification is a crime, as Law Minister of India Mr. Khurshid is well aware of that fact. Still it looks like allegation not evidence, Right! Then came the final revelation is 2012, when Mrs. Khurshid came up to fight local assembly elections.
Here is the clinching evidence http://myneta.info/up2012/candidate.php?candidate_id=1114 Mrs. Khurshid's disclosure
She states that same family asset is 48 million and not 62 million, poor Salman, surely in 2012 your bad times has come up; But Devil lies in details:
This time election commission had asked to furnish income also and Mrs. Khurshid complies ( and I copy & paste ):
Person Financial Year Taxable Income
Mrs. Khurshid 2010 - 2011 Rs 3,07,102 ~ 3 Lacs+
Mr. Khurshid 2010 - 2011 Rs 8,61,115 ~ 8 Lacs+
dependent1 2010 - 2011 Rs 1,48,970 ~ 1 Lacs+
dependent2 2010 - 2011 Rs 1,51,890 ~ 1 Lacs+
OMG! No Bill gates or Donald Trump or Ambani scale earning? Then how could he or Mrs. Khurshid purchase all these land!
Those huge cash given in 2011 are now back in the banks! Good good, has Mr. Khurshid shown the interest of the bank accounts inn the taxable income from Rs. 12.5 million (1,25 crore) in taxable income??? Not clear, facts show very less chance of being so! At least 5 lacs of bank interest is not shown in taxable income!
Remember those buildings Mrs. Khurshid received from her father as gift, they are shown at 15 lacs and not 4 lacs, still nowhere near the real value of a beachfront property at Calanghute, Goa. She further states these were not gifts but "Inherited". Another discrepancy!
RESIDENT FLAT A BERNARD SIMON COMPLEX CANDILIM GOA
Total Area
Built Up Area 2000Sq.fit
Whether Inherited Y
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
15,00,000 15 Lacs+
RES FLAT B BERNARD SIMON COMPLEX CANDOLIM GOA
Total Area
Built Up Area 2000Sq.ft.
Whether Inherited Y
Purchase Date 0000-00-00
Purchase Cost 0.00
Development Cost 0.00
15,00,000 15 Lacs+
She further states, she owns a residential building since 2002, which Salman had never mentioned in his previous disclosures, neither in 2009 nor in 2011 ( Once maybe a mistake, twice proves a pattern for a crime), how can you forget to mention something you own for nearly a decade,Mr. Khurshid, when you don't really own that much.:)
VILL.SATOLI TEH DIST NENITAL
Total Area
Built Up Area 4Nali
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2002-11-15
Purchase Cost 1400000.00
Development Cost 0.00
16,50,000 16 Lacs+
Louise Khurshid also mentioned that she had 6 plots (huge ones) not 3 as Salman khurshid had stated, and the purchase dates show that she had most of them before 2009 (Marked in Red) also!
JAFAR,KHURSHID ,SAMAR AND UMAR VILL.STORI DIST NENITAL
Total Area 90Nali
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2002-03-31
Purchase Cost 814765.00
Development Cost 0.00
58,56,000 58 Lacs+
JAFAR,KHURSHID ,SAMAR AND UMAR VILL.STORI DIST NENITAL
Total Area 19Nali
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2001-03-30
Purchase Cost 497000.00
Development Cost 0.00
14,96,000 14 Lacs+
JAFAR,SAMAR,UMAR VILL.DHARMPUR BLOOK KAYMGANJ JANPAD FARRUKHABAD
Total Area 32Bidha
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2010-03-09
Purchase Cost 820500.00
Development Cost 0.00
12,00,000 12 Lacs+
JAFAR,SAMAR,UMAR VILL.DHARMPUR BLOOK KAYMGANJ JANPAD FARRUKHABAD
Total Area 31Bidha
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2010-03-09
Purchase Cost 775000.00
Development Cost 0.00
8,50,000 8 Lacs+
JAFAR,SAMAR,UMAR VILL.GANIPUR JOGPUR BLOCK NVABGAN JANPAD FARRUKHABAD
Total Area 31Bidha
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2010-03-09
Purchase Cost 775000.00
Development Cost 0.00
8,50,000 8 Lacs+
JAFAR,SAMAR,UMAR VILL.ROHILA DIST GOTAM BUDDHNAGAR
Total Area 30Bidha
Whether Inherited N
Purchase Date 2006-01-01
Purchase Cost 300000.00
Development Cost 0.00
1,20,00,000 1 Crore+
That means Lousie Khurshid bought land worth 28 lakh in just one day, 9th March 2010! Now her annual income is just 3 lakh, total family income is just 13 lakh a year! So what was the source of this money. Please explain!
If it is just astute financial planning, we demand to know the details.
They claim to be social workers and devoted their life well-being of poor people, when we in India, have highest number of malnutrition cases, poverty is increasing, global economy in turmoil, he himself & his family goes scouting for agricultural land, which are close to F1 racing circuit at Goutam Buddhanagar & owning more 40% of a cold storage ( Value shown Rs. 0) ! On some searching on google, I find that kaimganj area has just 4 cold storage with combined capacity of 2545 mt., the value can't be 0.
So some pointed questions for them.
1. Name the sources of Income for Mrs. Louise Khurshid's one day land buying spree on 9th march 2010 amounting over 28 lacs?
2. Name the sources of Income for purchase of following cars ( as they are shown as dependent and having taxable income of 1 lakh each and they also don't have car loans)?
| VERNA 7,50,052 |
| MARUTI SWIFT 5,47,766 |
3. Why are they buying agricultural land and showing no development cost, are they doing real farming? if so, how many people they employ? Why their salary will not go under development cost?
4. What are their agricultural income from farming & cold storage? Why are they not showing them in any asset & income disclosures?
Nation needs answers and accountability, Mr. Law Minister! Shape up or Ship out!
That's the call from me as one of
common Indians, The Mango People!
